Hi Dutch.

It's a pity it isn't, mine works like it should every time.

If I turn off the ELEV paddle, I have full control of the pitch using the pitch trim wheel. Turn the ELEV paddle back on, and it will hold the pitch that I set it at. Both UP and DOWN. I must admit that pushing down is a bit trickier, but it still works 100% of the time for me. So it is OFF when I turn it OFF, and ON when I turn it ON.

If I turn off the AIL paddle, I have full control of the turning of the 737, it does not fight me at all. It also works 100% of the time. So this too, is OFF when I turn it OFF, and ON when I turn it ON.

It also performs exactly the same in P3D as it does in FSX, just like it should. :-/