Well, as an AVSIM staff reviewer, I don't know that I would agree with your characterization.  I am free to say what I want to say and take pains to point out the deficiencies in any product I review.  All of them have good points and bad points.  You wouldn't believe the number of hours I spend working through the 767, flight after flight, so I can provide an accurate assessment.  I have to be the one to eventually be in a position to answer all the questions.  That's why I've been working on this particular review since July and don't consider it close to being finished.  Even then it's just my opinion.

Is it going to get a good review?  Everyone gets to wait and see, including Captain Sim.  I can tell you it will be as accurate as I know how to make it.  Programing details aren't important though.  If I get 20 FPS I'll say so.  Same if I get 5, or 40.  In the end, if I can have a smooth experience with some personally acceptable level of compromise, I don't do shift+z much.

Perhaps your being banned over there has contributed to your unpleasant feelings toward AVSIM?  Just relax.  This is a fun hobby.  People let too much drama interfere with their enjoyment sometimes.  If you make a navigational error, just get back on course and enjoy the flight.  No offense intended.

I have been simming a long time, and the issue of complex add-ons and third party weather is nothing new.