Thank you so much for the reply!

The first time, and every time after the second, I could not get the switch to toggle at any time, anywhere. All times were started cold and dark I think, tho I'll double check that.

Other aircraft don't have this issue with multiple engines tho...? Either way, this isn't a make or break issue for me, but the AP definitely is!

Yes, I did mess with it on the EFB. It shows the weight way out of bounds. It goes out of bounds once the fuel passes 9% full. The more full it gets, the further it goes out.